Try TBH inside ChatGPT. Click here
3 Lightweight Tools to Nurture Candidates Without an ATS
Updated: Thu, Apr 24, 2025
Adejoke (JK) Adekunle
Recruiting at small agencies presents unique challenges. Without the budget for a full-fledged Applicant Tracking System (ATS), many recruiters struggle to maintain meaningful connections with candidates throughout the hiring process. However, the absence of an ATS doesn't mean you can't deliver a stellar candidate experience. This article explores three efficient, lightweight tools that help small agency recruiters nurture candidate relationships effectively without breaking the bank.
Why Candidate Nurturing Matters in Small Agencies
Candidate nurturing—the process of building and maintaining relationships with potential hires—has become increasingly crucial in today's competitive talent market. According to LinkedIn's Global Talent Trends report, 77% of candidates base their decision to accept an offer on their experience during the recruitment process.
For small recruiting agencies operating without an ATS, maintaining these relationships manually becomes incredibly time-consuming. The good news is that purpose-built lightweight tools can fill this gap without requiring the significant investment an enterprise ATS demands.
The Cost of Poor Candidate Communication
Before diving into solutions, it's important to understand what's at stake. Poor candidate communication leads to:
- Damaged employer brand reputation
- Higher candidate dropout rates
- Increased time-to-hire
- Lost referral opportunities
- Difficulty rebuilding talent pools for future positions
A study by CareerBuilder found that 78% of candidates would tell others about a bad application experience, while 62% would actively discourage others from applying to the organization. These statistics highlight why investing in candidate nurturing tools is essential, even for small operations.
Tool 1: TBH - Interview Feedback Made Human
Small agencies often struggle with collecting and sharing meaningful interview feedback, leading to delays in the hiring process and a poor candidate experience. TBH addresses this challenge by humanizing the feedback collection process.
What Makes TBH Stand Out for Small Agencies
TBH has reimagined the interview feedback process with a human-centered approach that's particularly valuable for small recruiting teams. Instead of complex systems requiring extensive training, TBH offers a lightweight solution focused on what matters most: clear, honest, and timely feedback.
Key Features That Small Agencies Will Love
- Voice-Based Feedback Collection: Interviewers can share their thoughts verbally rather than typing lengthy assessments, making feedback more authentic and detailed while saving valuable time.
- Pre-built, Customizable Templates: Start using the system immediately with ready-made feedback forms that can be tailored to match your specific hiring needs.
- Automatic Hire/No-Hire Recommendations: The platform analyzes feedback across interviewers to generate consistent hiring recommendations, helping small teams make decisions with confidence.
- Candidate-Ready Follow-ups: Transform interview feedback into professional, constructive communications that can be shared directly with candidates, eliminating ghosting and enhancing transparency.
- Collaboration Tools: Ensures all team members—even in distributed small agencies—can align on candidate evaluations without lengthy meetings.
For small agencies where each team member often wears multiple hats, TBH removes the administrative burden of feedback collection while improving the quality of insights gathered. This leads to better hiring decisions and a more positive experience for candidates, even without an enterprise-level ATS.
Enhance your candidate experience
Try TBH to help candidates understand how to do better
Tool 2: Streak CRM for Gmail - Relationship Management in Your Inbox
Many small recruiting agencies already operate primarily through email. Streak leverages this existing workflow by transforming Gmail into a lightweight CRM specifically designed for relationship management.
How Streak Supports Candidate Nurturing
Streak integrates directly with Gmail, allowing recruiters to track candidate communication without switching between multiple platforms. This seamless integration makes it ideal for small agencies that can't afford the time or resources for complex system implementations.
Standout Features for Recruiters
- Email Tracking: Know exactly when candidates open emails, allowing for perfectly timed follow-ups that feel natural rather than automated.
- Pipeline Visualization: Create customized recruiting pipelines that give you at-a-glance visibility into where each candidate stands in your process.
- Snippets and Templates: Save time with reusable email templates that can be personalized for each candidate interaction, ensuring consistent yet personalized communication.
- Shared Communication History: Everyone on your small team can see the complete interaction history with candidates, preventing redundant questions or outreach.
- Meeting Scheduling: Coordinate interviews efficiently without the back-and-forth email chains that frustrate candidates and waste recruiter time.
The beauty of Streak lies in its invisibility to candidates—they simply experience responsive, well-coordinated communication without realizing you're using a system to manage the relationship. This creates the impression of personalized attention that candidates value, regardless of your agency size.
Tool 3: Airtable - Flexible Candidate Database Without the Complexity
For small agencies needing something more structured than spreadsheets but less complex than an ATS, Airtable offers the perfect middle ground. This flexible database tool combines the familiarity of spreadsheets with powerful database capabilities.
Why Airtable Works for Candidate Nurturing
Airtable's visual, collaborative platform allows small recruiting teams to create custom candidate tracking systems without any coding knowledge. The highly customizable nature means you build exactly what you need—nothing more, nothing less.
Recruiter-Friendly Features
- Custom Views: Create different ways to visualize your candidate pool—kanban boards for tracking progress, calendars for scheduling follow-ups, or gallery views for comparing candidate profiles.
- Automations: Set up automatic reminders for candidate follow-ups, ensuring no potential hire falls through the cracks due to your busy schedule.
- Form Integration: Create branded application forms that feed directly into your database, eliminating manual data entry and reducing errors.
- Rich Media Storage: Attach resumes, portfolio samples, interview recordings, and notes all in one place for comprehensive candidate profiles.
- Collaboration Tools: Comment directly on candidate records, assign team members to specific follow-up tasks, and track engagement across your small team.
Airtable's flexibility makes it particularly valuable for small agencies with unique workflows or specialized recruiting niches. You can adapt the system as your agency grows or as your processes evolve, without the constraints of more rigid platforms.
Creating a Connected Ecosystem for Candidate Nurturing
While each of these tools is powerful on its own, their real strength emerges when used together to create a lightweight yet comprehensive candidate nurturing ecosystem:
- Capture Applications with Airtable forms to collect candidate information in a structured database.
- Manage Communication with Streak to track email interactions and schedule timely follow-ups.
- Gather and Share Feedback with TBH to make the interview process more human and transparent.
This connected approach gives small recruiting agencies the ability to deliver an enterprise-level candidate experience without the enterprise-level budget or implementation headaches.
Implementation Tips for Success
Adopting new tools, even lightweight ones, requires thoughtful implementation. Here are strategies to ensure success:
- Start Small: Begin with one tool that addresses your most pressing pain point rather than implementing all three simultaneously.
- Define Clear Processes: Document exactly how the tool will be used within your existing workflow before implementation.
- Train Your Team Thoroughly: Even intuitive tools require proper training to ensure consistent usage across your agency.
- Gather Feedback: Regularly check in with both recruiters and candidates to measure the impact of your new tools.
- Iterate and Improve: Use insights from the first few months to refine your processes and tool configurations.
Remember that technology alone won't solve candidate nurturing challenges—these tools simply enable your team to be more consistent and efficient in their relationship-building efforts.
Measuring Success: Beyond the Hire
How do you know if your lightweight candidate nurturing tools are actually working? Look beyond just making placements to these key performance indicators:
- Candidate Net Promoter Score: Ask candidates to rate their experience and likelihood to recommend your agency.
- Time-to-Feedback: Measure how quickly interviewers provide feedback and how soon candidates receive communications.
- Candidate Dropout Rate: Track whether fewer candidates withdraw from your process after implementing better nurturing tools.
- Referral Rates: Note whether more candidates are referring colleagues to your agency.
- Reengagement Success: Monitor how many candidates from your database respond positively when contacted about new opportunities.
These metrics provide tangible evidence of improved candidate relationships, which ultimately leads to more successful placements and a stronger reputation for your agency.
Conclusion: Human-Centered Tools for Human-Centered Recruiting
Effective candidate nurturing doesn't require massive investment in enterprise software—it requires thoughtful selection of tools that enhance rather than replace the human element of recruiting. The three lightweight solutions explored in this article—TBH, Streak, and Airtable—each address different aspects of the nurturing process while keeping the focus where it belongs: on building meaningful candidate relationships.
For small recruiting agencies, these tools offer a way to compete with larger firms by delivering exceptional candidate experiences without the overhead of complex systems. By implementing even one of these solutions, you can significantly improve your ability to nurture candidates throughout their journey, leading to better placements and a stronger reputation in the marketplace.
Remember that technology should serve your recruitment strategy, not define it. The most successful small agencies are those that find the right balance between efficient tools and the personal touch that candidates remember and value.
Table of Contents
Featured Podcast
Improve candidate experience in 7 minutes. Listen now.
FAQs
More information about this topic
Citations
- LinkedIn Global Talent Trends Report - Annual survey of over 7,000 talent professionals worldwide that tracks recruitment trends including candidate experience factors.
- CareerBuilder Candidate Experience Study - Research on how candidate experience affects employer brand and recruitment success.