Best Practices for Candidate Feedback: Improving Candidate Experience
Updated: Fri, Oct 25, 2024
Adejoke (JK) Adekunle
Providing feedback to job candidates is a crucial aspect of the hiring process that reflects your organization’s values, professionalism, and commitment to a positive candidate experience. Candidates dedicate time, energy, and often high expectations when applying for roles, and constructive feedback, whether they are accepted or rejected, can significantly enhance their perception of your company. Many organizations still view feedback as a “nice-to-have,” but research shows that it is a critical differentiator in building employer branding, strengthening talent pools, and improving hiring outcomes.
In this article, we’ll explore the best practices for giving candidate feedback, the impact it has on your organization, and how to structure and deliver it effectively. The overall aim is to help you create a more engaging and respectful hiring process that reflects well on your organization.
Importance of Feedback in Recruitment
Enhancing Employer Brand
It's touch competition in the talent acquisition market and as such, feedback has become a marker of a positive hiring experience. When candidates receive clear and actionable insights, it not only improves their experience but also promotes your organization as empathetic, attentive, and respectful. Candidates are likely to share their experiences on public forums or with peers, impacting your brand image directly. Positive experiences help distinguish your brand as one that respects candidates’ time and effort, boosting your reputation in the job market.
Fostering Better Talent Relationships
Rejections can discourage candidates, especially if they receive no response or a generic message. However, when rejection includes thoughtful feedback, it opens a dialogue. Constructive feedback acknowledges their time and effort, increasing the chances they might return for future roles that better match their skills and experience.
Strengthening Talent Pools
Feedback encourages candidates to consider your company for future roles, creating a stronger talent pipeline. Often, the skills that candidates lack for a particular position might not be a limiting factor for other roles within the organization. Providing feedback helps build a long-term talent pool that aligns with future requirements.
Reducing Rejection Anxiety
Candidates often feel uncertain when they receive rejection without context. Honest and respectful feedback helps to minimize the anxiety associated with rejections and fosters an environment where candidates feel respected. It also helps candidates identify areas for growth, boosting their career development.
Key Principles of Effective Feedback
Constructive feedback goes beyond a generic response; it should be actionable, specific, and respectful. Here are the core principles for providing effective candidate feedback:
Be Specific and Honest
Vague feedback is frustrating and unhelpful. Instead of saying “We went with someone with more experience,” mention the specific skills or experiences that aligned with the role. For example, “While your project management skills are strong, we were looking for experience with large-scale enterprise projects, which was a key requirement.”
Offer Actionable Advice
Feedback should provide candidates with suggestions on how they might improve their skills or approach. Actionable advice can encourage candidates to improve and come back with stronger applications in the future. For instance, “To increase your impact in interviews, you might consider detailing how you overcame specific challenges in past projects.”
Be Respectful and Courteous
The language used in feedback matters. Treat every candidate with respect, even when pointing out areas for improvement. Recognize their effort and make it clear that you value their time. Simple statements like, “Thank you for taking the time to prepare and interview with us,” can add a layer of warmth and respect.
Focus on Skills and Qualifications, Not Personal Attributes
Feedback should center on skills, qualifications, and experiences that align or misalign with the role. Avoid commenting on personal attributes or opinions about the candidate’s personality, as these can feel intrusive and inappropriate. Keep feedback professional by framing it around the job’s requirements.
Avoid Comparisons with Other Candidates
Comparisons can create an unhealthy sense of competition and negatively impact the candidate’s confidence. Instead, frame feedback around the candidate’s alignment with the role’s requirements. Rather than mentioning, “Another candidate had more experience in X,” focus on saying, “This role requires advanced experience in X, which we believe will best support our goals.”
Timeliness Matters
Feedback should be provided as soon as possible after a decision is made. Timeliness shows respect for the candidate’s time and keeps the interview process fresh in their mind, enabling them to act on the feedback more effectively. Candidates are more likely to appreciate feedback when it’s delivered promptly rather than weeks or months after their interview.
Enhance your candidate experience
Try TBH to help candidates understand how to do better
Constructive Criticism Approaches
- Focus on Specific Examples: Emphasize particular instances from the interview or application. This helps candidates understand their performance better. For example, instead of saying, "You need to improve," you can point out, "In the technical interview, you could have elaborated more on your coding approach."
- Balance Positives and Negatives: Apply the "sandwich" method in delivering positive feedback alongside areas needing improvement. This method softens the impact of criticism, making candidates more open to suggestions. For instance, "Your resume is well organized, but the format could highlight your skills more effectively. Overall, your experience is impressive."
- Encourage Self-Reflection: Ask candidates what they feel went well and what challenges they faced. This prompts self-assessment and growth, creating a dialog instead of a monologue. For example, you might ask, "What aspects of your presentation did you feel were strongest?"
- Acknowledge Strengths: Highlight candidates' strong attributes and achievements clearly. Say something like, "Your communication skills stood out during the interview." This helps to reinforce their confidence and encourage continued growth in those areas.
- Set Achievement Goals: I provide candidates with clear goals for their next steps. For instance, I might state, "To further enhance your profile, consider gaining experience in project management. This could position you strongly for future opportunities."
- Create a Supportive Environment: I cultivate an environment that values development by encouraging candidates to reach out for further guidance. A simple invitation such as "Feel free to connect if you have questions as you prepare for your next steps," promotes ongoing communication and learning.
Handling Challenging Scenarios
Candidate feedback isn’t always straightforward, and certain scenarios may require additional sensitivity. For example:
Handling Feedback for High-Performing Candidates Who Were Rejected
When a high-performing candidate is not selected, it’s crucial to convey that the decision was difficult. Let them know that their qualifications were impressive and that the choice was based on specific job requirements or nuances. Acknowledge their skills and leave the door open for future opportunities, creating a positive association with your brand.
Providing Feedback for Interns and Entry-Level Roles
Candidates for these positions often lack experience, so it’s essential to provide feedback that encourages growth. Rather than focusing on experience gaps, focus on skills and qualities that they can develop. For instance, “Building your project management skills could make a strong difference in your career path.”
Dealing with Rejected Internal Candidates
Internal candidates may feel particularly disappointed when they’re rejected. It’s essential to show appreciation for their contributions to the organization and offer advice that could help them secure future roles. Providing detailed feedback is critical in these cases to maintain morale and foster career development within the organization.
Delivery Methods for Candidate Feedback
Choosing the right delivery method for feedback is essential. The way feedback is conveyed can impact how it’s received. Here are some options to consider:
Email Feedback
Email feedback is often the most practical choice for high-volume hiring. It allows you to share feedback quickly while ensuring that candidates have written details they can revisit. However, make sure the email is personalized and specific to avoid sounding generic. You can use a tool like TBH to make sure of that.
Phone Feedback
When candidates reach later stages of the interview process, a phone call can be a respectful way to offer feedback. Phone conversations allow for a more personalized approach, enabling you to provide clarification and answer questions. It also shows that your organization values candidates, even if they weren’t selected.
In-Person Feedback for Final Rounds
For candidates who reach the final interview stages, an in-person or virtual meeting might be the most respectful approach. This method demonstrates a commitment to the candidate’s development and offers a chance to discuss feedback in a two-way conversation.
Timely and tailored feedback fosters a culture of transparency that attracts top talent. It’s essential to remember that each piece of feedback is an opportunity for growth and connection. Embracing these best practices can transform the candidate experience and contribute to a more inclusive and effective recruitment process. Cheers!
Table of Contents
Featured Podcast
Improve candidate experience in 7 minutes. Listen now.
FAQs
More information about this topic