The Impact of Candidate Feedback on Employer Branding
Updated: Fri, Nov 1, 2024
Adejoke (JK) Adekunle
The influence of candidate feedback on employer branding is profound, reshaping perceptions of companies in today’s competitive hiring landscape. As organizations strive to attract and retain top talent, the experiences shared by job candidates are pivotal in influencing how potential employees, customers, and stakeholders view a company. Positive candidate feedback can drive a company’s reputation as a desirable place to work, while negative feedback can have the opposite effect. With the rise of online review platforms and social media, where candidates freely express their experiences, companies are more visible than ever. This openness underscores the importance of managing the candidate experience from start to finish.
Let us take a deep dive into how candidate feedback influences employer branding and why it’s a crucial strategy for any organization looking to stand out and attract top talent.
Candidate Feedback: A Double-Edged Sword for Employer Branding
In an era of unprecedented transparency, candidate feedback has become both a powerful asset and a potential liability for employer branding. Candidates today have access to platforms like Glassdoor, Indeed, and LinkedIn, where they can share their interview experiences, recruitment processes, and overall impressions of companies. A survey by Talent Board found that 71% of candidates share negative experiences with others, and over half would discourage others from applying to the company after a poor experience. These statistics highlight the importance of understanding the impact of feedback on a company’s reputation.
Negative feedback doesn’t just discourage potential candidates; it can harm brand equity. Conversely, positive candidate feedback strengthens employer branding, portraying the company as a supportive, engaging, and fair employer. In today’s tight labor market, the way candidates perceive their treatment during the recruitment process often determines if they will choose to accept or decline an offer.
The Importance of Candidate Experience in the Feedback Loop
Companies with a structured and supportive recruitment process tend to receive more favorable feedback, which in turn enhances their employer brand. According to LinkedIn’s research, companies with a strong employer brand receive 50% more qualified applicants and experience a 28% reduction in turnover rates. These findings illustrate the relationship between candidate feedback and employer branding outcomes.
Candidate experience extends beyond the interview stage; it includes every touchpoint, from the job posting to the final job offer or rejection. When candidates feel valued, respected, and fairly treated, they are more likely to leave positive reviews. Conversely, poor candidate experiences, such as lengthy or unclear hiring processes, can fuel negative feedback and drive talent to competitors. Research from IBM Smarter Workforce Institute revealed that candidates who have a positive recruitment experience are 80% more likely to apply again even after getting declined.
Key Elements Shaping Candidate Feedback
The journey that candidates undergo from application to final decision encompasses several critical elements, each of which contributes to their overall experience. When any part of this journey is mishandled, candidates may leave negative feedback, impacting employer branding.
- Transparency and Communication
Transparency is foundational to a positive candidate experience. Candidates seek clear communication regarding job expectations, compensation, and timelines. When companies fail to communicate adequately, it often results in frustration and dissatisfaction. - Response Time
Timely responses are essential, as prolonged silences can lead candidates to feel undervalued. A survey by CareerBuilder found that 75% of candidates never hear back from companies after applying, which contributes to poor candidate experience. Prompt communication, even if it is a rejection, is appreciated and perceived as respectful by most candidates. - Respectful Rejection
Candidates who are rejected often want constructive feedback, but few companies provide it. A study by Talent Board found that 70% of candidates are more likely to reapply to a company if they receive constructive feedback after a rejection. Respectful rejections and useful feedback can positively impact the employer’s brand, showing a commitment to candidates’ career growth, even if they aren’t hired immediately. - Fair and Efficient Interview Processes
An effective interview process that minimizes stress, respects candidates' time, and assesses skills objectively contributes to positive candidate feedback. Long, grueling interview processes create negative experiences, with 83% of candidates in a LinkedIn survey reporting they would not apply to the same company again after a negative interview experience. - Employer Follow-Up
Candidates highly appreciate follow-ups. According to Talent Board, 69% of candidates who receive an employer follow-up would recommend the company to others, regardless of the outcome. Follow-ups reinforce a company’s commitment to treating candidates as individuals and not just applicants, a quality highly regarded in employer branding.
How Candidate Feedback Affects Employer Branding
Statistics surrounding candidate feedback illustrate the far-reaching effects of both positive and negative candidate experiences:
- Brand Loyalty: Candidates will wait longer for a response if a company has a strong employer brand. Brand loyalty among candidates, even those who are rejected, can foster a network of goodwill, increasing brand visibility and appeal.
- Reputation and Profitability: An article from Harvard Business Review revealed that a poor reputation costs companies 10% more per hire. Negative candidate feedback can hurt a company’s financials directly through increased hiring costs and indirectly through reduced productivity.
- Referral Power: The Talent Board’s Candidate Experience Research Report shows that 69% of candidates would not recommend a company to others after a poor experience. Referrals are one of the most effective recruitment strategies; thus, maintaining a strong employer brand is vital to encourage employees and former candidates to refer top talent.
- Social Media Amplification: A study by Talent Board found that 72% of job seekers who have had a bad experience will share it online, and 64% of candidates say a poor experience would make them less likely to purchase products or services from that company.
Enhance your candidate experience
Try TBH to help candidates understand how to do better
Leveraging Candidate Feedback for Improved Employer Branding
Candidate feedback can provide companies with valuable insights into what aspects of their recruitment processes need improvement. Organizations that actively seek and act on this feedback stand to gain several advantages in employer branding.
- Feedback Collection Mechanisms
Implementing regular surveys or feedback forms after each hiring stage allows companies to identify pain points in the candidate experience. For example, a short post-interview survey asking candidates to rate their experience on aspects like clarity, interviewer friendliness, and overall satisfaction can yield actionable insights. - Addressing Negative Feedback
Public platforms often host both positive and negative feedback. While responding to positive comments is beneficial, addressing negative reviews can be equally impactful. When companies take the time to respond to candidate criticisms and offer solutions or apologies, they demonstrate accountability, which can soften public perception and reassure future applicants. - Training Recruitment Teams
Employers can improve their brand by training recruitment teams to prioritize candidate experience. Programs that focus on empathetic communication, transparency, and effective follow-up are instrumental in ensuring candidates feel valued. When recruiters are equipped to handle candidate interactions skillfully, positive feedback is more likely. - Feedback as a Branding Tool
Many companies now feature candidate testimonials on their career pages. Sharing positive candidate experiences through blogs, videos, or social media posts boosts employer branding by illustrating an engaging recruitment process. Highlighting the experiences of previously rejected candidates who later succeeded with the company can also demonstrate resilience, fair treatment, and company growth. - Analyzing Trends in Candidate Feedback
Regular analysis of feedback trends allows companies to identify recurring issues. An increase in complaints about a lack of feedback after interviews, for instance, suggests that candidates feel ignored. Addressing such issues can prevent further negative reviews, helping companies maintain a positive employer brand image.
Case Studies: The Role of Candidate Feedback in Employer Branding
Examining real-world examples reveals how candidate feedback has impacted companies’ reputations, both positively and negatively.
- LinkedIn’s “Good Employee Experience” Program
LinkedIn’s reputation as an employee-first brand is widely recognized, partially due to its focus on candidate experience. LinkedIn consistently ranks highly on Glassdoor, with candidates and employees praising its transparent and organized hiring process. By emphasizing communication, LinkedIn encourages candidates to leave positive feedback, which strengthens its employer brand and attracts high-quality talent. - United Airlines’ Recruitment Overhaul
United Airlines faced significant criticism from candidates regarding its lengthy and ambiguous recruitment process. Negative reviews on social media impacted its reputation, but instead of ignoring the criticism, United revamped its hiring process by simplifying its recruitment stages and improving communication. This shift resulted in higher candidate satisfaction, reflected in an increase in positive feedback online.
The ROI of Prioritizing Candidate Feedback for Employer Branding
Prioritizing candidate feedback in employer branding efforts yields a significant return on investment (ROI) through improved brand perception, higher quality hires, and increased employee loyalty. Data from Glassdoor reveals that companies investing in employer branding see a 33% rise in applicant quality and a 50% reduction in hiring costs. Positive candidate feedback is central to these outcomes, as it demonstrates a company’s commitment to fairness, transparency, and respect.
Effective employer branding built on positive candidate feedback contributes to a healthy workplace culture and a reputation as an employer of choice. As organizations increasingly recognize the impact of candidate feedback on employer branding, implementing strategies to enhance the candidate experience will become a priority in differentiating top companies from the rest.
References
- The Definitive Guide to Candidate Experience
- LinkedIn Business Report
- Rethinking The Candidate Experience
- Career Builder
- How to Provide Feedback Candidates Will Appreciate
- The Importance of Candidate Experience
- 100 Recruitment Statistics and Trends for 2024 and Beyond
- Harvard Business Review
- What are the key metrics and benchmarks for candidate experience in your industry?
- The Most Important Employer Branding Statistics to Know
Table of Contents
Featured Podcast
Improve candidate experience in 7 minutes. Listen now.
FAQs
More information about this topic